For what you listed..... I would recommend a gen 2 busa over the buell! I am 5'8" at 170lbs. And the big girl isnt as bad as you think for around town riding. 2 up it is great at! My girl picks this bike over my 09 1k to ride 2 up one. The busa has been super reliable, ton of parts available, and a great source of info on. Out of the box it is a better made bike then the buell! Only mods I would recommend to you for helping you with owning a busa... Get a full pipe or slip ons to lose close to 33lbs. 2 up rear sprocket and speedohealer. Seriously you will behead in the long run!