apples and oranges, Gen I is the civic in every respect, while gen II are considered more like Escalades.. I beat them both up for a short time, but when it came time to down sized, the harley and the Gen II had to go.. Gen I is vicious, you make a mistake and she will bite you, Gen II felt a bit more friendly and I was getting to comfy with it... and that is not a good feeling,,, definately scrape more parts on her in 1 year than the Gen II in 3