I find it rather amusing that there are some here trying to deflect HIS responsibility in the matter...doesn't matter if she was a prostitute, if he KNEW she was underaged, he made a bad decision. You guys can pick her apart all you want, she was underaged and what he did was wrong. What she did (and may still do) is sad and pathetic, but what he did was illegal.
There's no gray area here...right vs. wrong...legal vs. illegal...I can't understand any reason to deflect the responsibility from him. And I hold those same feelings for women that pray on boys. This isn't an issue of men vs. women, it's adults and the limits they KNOW EXIST when it comes to minors...
So for those of you saying no grey area....you get a ticket for 56 mph in a 55 mph zone...automatic ticket, no questions asked, doesnt matter the circumstances? This obviously is a far stretch, the crime we are speaking of is much more serious.
There should be some type of consequences for her. While he should have walked away, she should have some type of punishment too.
I find it rather amusing that there are some here trying to deflect HIS responsibility in the matter...doesn't matter if she was a prostitute, if he KNEW she was underaged, he made a bad decision. You guys can pick her apart all you want, she was underaged and what he did was wrong. What she did (and may still do) is sad and pathetic, but what he did was illegal.
There's no gray area here...right vs. wrong...legal vs. illegal...I can't understand any reason to deflect the responsibility from him. And I hold those same feelings for women that pray on boys. This isn't an issue of men vs. women, it's adults and the limits they KNOW EXIST when it comes to minors...
So for those of you saying no grey area....you get a ticket for 56 mph in a 55 mph zone...automatic ticket, no questions asked, doesnt matter the circumstances? This obviously is a far stretch, the crime we are speaking of is much more serious.
There should be some type of consequences for her. While he should have walked away, she should have some type of punishment too.
well I'm with you on this one. I DO have a 16 yo daughter and I would EXPECT an leo to be protecting her not flirting w herI have an 8 year old daughter who will be 16 before I know it, so I'm sort of prejudiced on this subject - if a 41 year old man touched her, especially an authority figure, no matter the circumstances, you'd have to lock him up or I'd kill him.
She may have known 'exactly what she was doing', but she's still a juvenile for a reason - he was an adult who was supposed to be responsible for himself, and others. The portion of a young adults brain that controls judgement doesn't even fully develop until after 20, so she didn't know 'exactly' what she was doing to herself. What I want to know is where was this girls Dad? I suspect broken home? What you see in her is the sad result of poor parenting. What's you buddies excuse?
Sorry, a little emotional on this subject.
Lots of debate about what should or shouldn't be. None of that is relevant so fuggedaboudit. The only way it becomes relevant is when we talk about what laws should be changed, etc.
In this instance, there is definitely a black and white situation and it is this: if you're over 18, don't have sex with someone who's under 18.
That's it.
The sentence fits the crime if only for one reason: It shows a lack of judgment on the part of your friend. Do we want a guy who is supposed to be enforcing the law to be able to break the law with impunity? Hardly. The judge gave him a slight break so he needs to just be glad of it and do his time for it.
I gave up a friendship with a so-called friend who had sex with an underage girl, a similar situation to your friend's except my former friend wasn't a police officer. I thought about it long and hard and finally realized that as a friend, I would never be able to trust him again. Very tragic.
Don't get me wrong, I believe in supporting my friends but not when they're showing poor judgment like this. Supporting my friends means helping them do the right things for the right reasons, not backing their play when they're effing up theirs or others' lives.
I have sympathy for you, but not for him.
--Wag--
So for those of you saying no grey area....you get a ticket for 56 mph in a 55 mph zone...automatic ticket, no questions asked, doesnt matter the circumstances? This obviously is a far stretch, the crime we are speaking of is much more serious.
There should be some type of consequences for her. While he should have walked away, she should have some type of punishment too.