Okay guys. I am certain that what I am about to write here is not going to be very popular. But before I get into my opinions on the subject I want to recognize that there are some excellent arguments that have been made here about what RTVEGAS and I saw at Starbucks that day. I appreciate what many of you have had to say about this topic. I wanted to wait to respond because this thread because I knew some of you would likely be able to give me some new perspective and some things to think about, which you did.
This is not the first time we saw this bike park at a Handicap spot at that Starbucks. We saw this bike parked there sometime late last year. We mentioned out loud how we thought that it was inappropriate for a motorcycle to park in a handicap space. We did not know that they even gave out handicap stickers for motorcycles. In all my years I had never heard of it. We thought it was just some Harley parked in a Handicap spot. The owner of the motorcycle hobbled around the corner and confronted us. He said; “If you want to assume that I can't park there you should check my license plate." We checked it and saw the handicap sticker.
First, a little about me and how I know RTVEGAS.
He and I work together. I come from a family of Healthcare workers. I have been working in Healthcare as an EMT, in ER's and in Medical laboratories since 1994. I work with RTVEGAS at a hospital and his background in Healthcare is more extensive then mine, about 18 years or so. I have been riding for about 15 years have more then a hundred thousand miles of riding under my belt.
Point 1: Just because they are handicapped, they should not be denied their right to ride.
Counter Point 1: Just because you are able to ride does not mean you should be riding. Think of a S.Q.U.I.D. riding like an idiot and popping wheelies in heavy traffic. They are more then able to ride but they have no business being on a bike. You have to take a test to get your drivers license and your motorcycle endorsement and they can both be taken away. That makes riding and driving a privilege that you have to earn. If you are a danger to yourself or others, you might not get to keep your license or your endorsement.
Bottom line: Riding, or driving for that matter, is not a right... it is a privilege
Point 2: He is handicapped but has good control of the bike. He just can't breathe very well or walk very far when he gets where he is going. He needs the Handicap space to park close.
Counter Point 2: Riding is exponentially more dangerous then driving a car. If you can't walk or breathe when something bad happens and you are forced to lay your bike down, you are far more likely to be critically injured. I know this from experiences I have had out in the field working in Healthcare. Even when wearing full gear, the level of severity for injuries increases dramatically. It is especially dangerous when it comes to a person with respiratory problems. You are endangering yourself and others on the road.
Bottom Line: If you can't walk more then a couple of feet or have serious respiratory problems, you have no business riding a motorcycle. You need to be in a car for your safety and mine.
Point 3: There are usually plenty of handicap spaces anyway.
Counter Point 3: That is just not always the case. My grandmother had a stroke a few years back and after she had recuperated enough to drive she had a handicapped placard for her car. There were too many times that she was not able to park in a handicap space because there simply were not enough spaces. There were times that I would help her shop and we would take her car. I saw people that were far less handicapped then her speeding into a space right in front of us right before they got out of the car and briskly walked away. You can imagine how that made me and my grandmother feel.
Bottom Line: If are severely and legitimately handicapped, you deserve the space. If you are not and use the space anyway, you are taking it away from someone that really needs it.
Point 4: If I qualify for a sticker and I can get one for my bike, why shouldn’t I? It’s not my fault that the system is set up that way.
Counter Point 4: I used to live in New Mexico. When I originally went to college out of High School I qualified for a few special types of financial aide and scholarships because one of my great grandparents was full blooded Native American. I barely made the cut, but I had enough Native American ancestry to qualify. I never took advantage of it though, because I felt it was not right. That money was set aside for people of direct Native American descendants to help them get off the reservation and get an education. I already had opportunities enough. If I used that money, I felt like it would not be proper. My dad was a Marine Corps Drill Instructor and I believe in what he said about taking things that don’t belong to you and taking advantage of things that were not meant for you. That money was never intended for people like me, even though I did qualify for it.
Bottom Line: Just because the system allows it does not mean our personal ethical integrity can be ignored.
Please keep in mind that I’m not saying anyone out there who has a handicap sticker on their bike should give it up. This is just what I think about the whole topic from my own experiences and life. Most of the time I can park closer then the Harley at that same Starbucks, there is sidewalk parking there for motorcycles.
But the most important thing to keep in mind: What the hell do I really know about anything anyway? It’s just my opinion and I have been wrong often enough.