HT USMC,
I had a cager sideswipe me...his insurance had to pay-no fault of mine....here's the condensed version of what went down with me dealing with his insurance company..
I took my bike to my dealer to have them do a damage estimate....They estimated nearly 7800.00 worth of damage including labor costs..
I sent the damage estimate to his insurance along with pics of damage to my bike...
They estimated that it might total out my bike...I have an '06..they said that if the damage totalled at least 70% of my bikes value, they would total it...
After they saw what the dealer was estimating, they decided to send their own PRIVATE adjuster out to do the damage estimate to see if what the dealer had listed was all really damaged from the wreck-- they told me that had the dealer estimate NOT been so high (and close to the 70% totalling value), they would not have sent the adjuster out-- they would have just cut me a check
But anyway, they sent him out and he came up with figures a lot lower than the dealers...imagine that!!!
I knew from what the private adjuster quoted me that I could NOT replace all damaged items back with OEM parts...when you start trying to buy OEM replacement stuff through the dealers, it is CCCOOOOOSSSSTTTLLLLYYYY!!
So, here I was with the problem: couldn't go back with all OEM stuff--too much cost, not enough money from the insurance company..
I shopped around and just STUMBLED across another dealer that told me they had a custom painter in Memphis who could repair the gouges in my front cowlings (like you've got) by plastic weld and re-contouring...then he could do a custom paint that would make everything good to go!!!
And as you see, HE HOOKED ME UUUUUUUPPPPP!!!!
Back to the insurance---I flat out asked the insurance rep I was dealing with if I could just get the check made out to ONLY ME.......NOT ME AND THE DEALERSHIP where I had the estimate done....I told her I really didn't like how the dealership was handling helping me with the estimate and expected repair time ( they were reaaallllyyy sssllllooowww), so I thought I would seek out another repair shop...
She told me the money was mine, I could find whomever I wanted to fix it==when they cut me the check, they considered it up to me to use whomever I wanted..I was free to use whomever....
So I recommend flat out asking them the same...if you have to tell them you don't know yet who you want to fix it..you're going to do some checking around to get your best deal..tell them to just cut it to you alone...I don't know if insurance companys have different policies on this, or if state laws differ on this, you'll have to check around...or maybe just ask YOUR insurance person..tell them what you're wanting to do and what to say to the other parties insurance...that's what I did...but my insurance agent is local and from a small town, that's why I could straight up talk to him like that...use your own judgement there..
anyway, that dealership I told you I stumbled upon did the custom paint, chrome rims, chrome rear sets/foot rests, chrome stator, clutch, and oil case, polished my frame and swingarm, full Muzzy 4-2-1 exhaust for a LOT less than what it would have cost to go back with all OEM stuff
So my suggestion to you is try to get the check cut to you, and go aftermarket baby!!!!!!! You'll like the results...I promise!!!
Oh, one last thing...I work for American Eurocopter in Mississippi...been over to the plant and worked there in Arlington for 'bout three months back in '03....Dallas/Arlington/Ft. Worth area is a different world from my small town in MS, but we all have the bad drivers to deal with!!!! There are some really bad drivers there though...it was like Nascar every day from my hotel to the plant there in Arlington!!!!
Good luck bro...I hope for the best for ya!!