I will throw a little more fuel on this fire.
I got the polished set in 2010 and was a little(lot) dismayed by what I got also!
The outer rims themselves were done to a chrome standard,amazing polish job,as good as I've seen.
Well the inner section was done amatuer(sp) style,basically an afterthought.More of less by hand(slight reflection),minor machine work swirls.
Basically as if done by someone who did not know how to polish or care.Out the door, next victim.
Send them back?,glad I did it myself, after reading this.
Spent 30 hrs to get them to this level,could have spent more time. I wanted/needed them for LSR and did not want the added headache of return and wait, and associated BS.
Do not have any before pics,why would I...-they looked like chit!
Unfortunatly this is standard business practice these days!-you bought them, hope you like em.
Tim, Sorry you don't have a choice, like I did.
Pursue it to the end,they need to send you out another set,in short order,no less.