Do You Believe In GOD ?

Wow, 14 pages and this has stayed very controlled being the type of subject it is. I am impressed. Figgured someone would be getting crucified by now :laugh:


I guess we need to turn up the heat with the question.......

Can God make a rock so heavy, even he can't lift it?
 
I guess we need to turn up the heat with the question.......

Can God make a rock so heavy, even he can't lift it?
Your question transcends the comprehendible abilities of the normal human mind. If you knew the answer you would not think it was worthy to ask, since you asked you do not know the answer.

If you do not readily know the answer, you do not fully understand the question hence you are unable to comprehend the correct answer even if it were provided to you.


However if you would like to entertain in depth philosophical positions on this question you can go here. It makes for an interesting read


Omnipotence paradox - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
 
I guess we need to turn up the heat with the question.......

Can God make a rock so heavy, even he can't lift it?

God tells us in the Quran "God is capable of doing anything He Wills to do." God never Wills to do anything that would make Him no longer be God. That is to say, He would never die as this would mean He is no longer "The Eternally Alive"

Therefore, He can make a rock so large or heavy - nothing in the entire universe can move it. As regards God "moving" it, He is not in the universe and He does not resemble His creation. Therefore, God is never subject to the Laws of the Creation because He is both the Creator and the Law Giver.
 
God tells us in the Quran "God is capable of doing anything He Wills to do." God never Wills to do anything that would make Him no longer be God. That is to say, He would never die as this would mean He is no longer "The Eternally Alive"

Therefore, He can make a rock so large or heavy - nothing in the entire universe can move it. As regards God "moving" it, He is not in the universe and He does not resemble His creation. Therefore, God is never subject to the Laws of the Creation because He is both the Creator and the Law Giver.

Nice.... :thumbsup:
 
That's a fair question. Here's a fair question which NOT ONE person has ever answered for me: If you discovered that there is no god, what would you do about it? --Wag--

Well I would wonder how Jesus came back to life. Cause not just the Bible knows that REALLY happened.
 
I hear this from time to time and it makes me wonder, just what pain is it that you're suffering? I don't mean to insult you personally, or any of the others who have expressed this sentiment. As I've said before, getting religion out of my life was the best thing that ever happened to me. My life improved dramatically in more ways than I can count. Without a religious faith, my spirituality has increased, etc. etc. I'm repeating myself. So, if I'm happier than I've ever been, why would it bother you that I don't believe in a universally supreme being? I don't get it. I'm happy but you're sad about it? Again, no personal affront is intended. --Wag--

Well it's kinda like knowing someone is getting on a train and YOU know it leads off a cliff. But that person doesnt believe you. Soon they will but it'll be too late.
 
And billions of lives have been changed by Buddhism. Tens of millions of lives have been changed by Islam. Hundreds of thousands by Paganism and Satanism. Thousands by Robert Kiyosaki. Proves exactly . . . . . . . . Nothing. --Wag--

All of those religions are missing one thing....a Savior that has defeated death.
 
Lou -

Not sure bro. seriously. that is one of those hypothetical questions that I feel is difficult to answer.

Because I am so convinced there is a God it is difficult for me to wrap my mind around "what if there wasn’t" does that make any sense?

--Snip--

Am I going to see you in December for the ride?

Ron, you are seriously the first person to EVER answer that question. Usually, I get a lot of shifting of feet, looking at the shoes, staring into space and a blatant avoidance of the question because . . .

. . . many people are afraid to explore the question. As you have demonstrated so clearly, there has been no harm in it!

To answer your question, however, "What would it take to get me to believe in god," the answer is also rather difficult. However, I have often heard believers who say they have a relationship with god or Jesus. That's fine. To become a believer, I'd have to have a similar relationship.

Now, to clarify what the means, there are some clarifications to the idea of the term "relationship" which may need to be stated. When I think of the term, "Relationship," I think of the kind of interaction that I have with my wife, my friends, my family. In spite of past attempts to have a relationship with god, that has never happened. Even my most sincere efforts after leaving the cult proved fruitless.

I never needed a flash of lightning, a visitation, a bonk on the head or the right scripture at the right time. All I wanted were answers to my prayers, even if the answer were, "No." All I needed, really, was the answer to one question and that was, "Where do I go from here?"

Frankly, that's all it would really take.

As for my question, I answered that in real life. I found that I could no longer believe that there was a god. I was angry at first, for about three seconds and then, realizing I had nothing to be mad at, the anger went away. The answer was, really, that not much about my life changed. A few things did. I had no more fear, no more guilt or anxiety and I became much more honest than I had before. Other than that, my life didn't really change a whole lot in terms of behavior and other than what I've said before in this thread.

I'm just rambling now.

I'm seriously considering the CA trip in December. I'll keep in tune with the thread!

--Wag--
 
Well it's kinda like knowing someone is getting on a train and YOU know it leads off a cliff. But that person doesnt believe you. Soon they will but it'll be too late.

Yes, but which one of us is on the train, really?

--Wag--
 
All of those religions are missing one thing....a Savior that has defeated death.

And that, of course, is the $64,000 question. (Though with the current economy, it's probably only worth $0.79! :D )

LOL

--Wag--
 
I believe I'll have a sandwich. All this food for thought has made me really hungry. GREAT THREAD BTW!!:beerchug:
 
I guess we need to turn up the heat with the question.......

Can God make a rock so heavy, even he can't lift it?

Or, even more difficult,

Can god make a pair of pants so slimming she won't ask, "do these pants make my ass look fat?"

cheers
ken
 
Last edited:
Here's a fair question which NOT ONE person has ever answered for me: If you discovered that there is no god, what would you do about it? --Wag--

i'll answer your question Wag but i have to say that most on here will probably not agree with me nor should this be taken for the norm...i have found that most people are nice for whatever reason, it took me hitting bottom and trying to scratch meaning out of this life by myself for a while to bring me to the realization that there is something bigger and more meaningful in this life than just trying to accumulate the most toys

it was during that time that i sensed God's presence and after finally acknowledging that He might be real and actually love me and want to help me that my life took a different track...the faith i received for a better future is the only thing keeping me from going back to the life i was living before...i know that God, my Creator, rescued me from a pointless life here on Earth and has promised me an even better existance in Heaven once i leave here

if it was proven beyond a shadow of a doubt that He truly does not exist and i am just an accidental by-product of a cosmic explosion, i have no doubt that i would return to the same life of lying, cheating, stealing, etc. that i used to live...if this is all there is, why not? i might as well do anything i want in order to get anything i want...there would be no meaning to life and nothing to stop me but some man-made rules which i don't give two hoots about...only the rules put in place by the One who created me mean anything as far as i am concerned
 
I Asked One Simple Question and WOW !!!! This is Good Stuff !!!

Thanks EVERYONE !!!!!!!!!!!!!!

God Bless !:whistle:
 
Back
Top