From the Author
Excerpt. © Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved.
Killing America Slowly
CHAPTER 12
Government actions which make no sense
The decision making process of bureaucracies could be compared to an elaborate puzzle game with rules that don't make any sense (see chapter “Evil driving principles of government's behaviorâ€), and played by many players. That is why the outcome of government's decisions often makes no sense as well. Here are a few examples of such actions which I hope will further convince you in the presence of my evil forces at play. Feel free to add to this list based on your personal experience.
Federal Govt: Salaries. Average personal income in 2012 was $42,693. Average personal income in Washington, D.C. Was $74,710. Do you personally have any say regarding what salaries should be paid to federal employees?
Local, State, and Federal Govt: Taxes. Do you think that taxes are too high? Do you have any control over how your taxes are being spent? Do you feel that big part of tax code is designed to squeeze more money out of you?
Local, State, and Federal Govt: Government spending. Do you have any idea where all the money goes? Have you ever seen a spreadsheet with all government spending drilled down to the smallest level of detail? Government officials would tell you that such detailed information does not exist, and you cannot view it. If the government doesn’t have that level of detail, they don’t know where the money is going. What is more important, if you don’t know where the money goes, you can’t make an informed decision whether these expenses make any sense.
Local, State, and Federal Govt: Outdated laws. It seems that new laws and regulations are created almost every day, growing the bureaucracy and increasing its complexity. What about old and outdated laws? Is anyone reviewing old laws and removing those which are outdated or no longer make sense?
Federal Govt: Use of Social Security Funds. The funds are meant to provide social security benefits, and are not supposed to be used for anything else. Federal government had no problem using the money for other purposes. It's not their money, so why not?
Federal Govt: Social Security Fund. By design of the government, working people are contributing to this fund, while retired workers receive compensation. Such mechanism is fundamentally flawed because it requires to have significantly more working people than retirees. Once the ratio changes, there is not enough working people to contribute, the fund is quickly depleted, and becomes insolvent. Why Social Security Fund was never transformed to work on the principles similar to 401(k) plans? This would promote personal responsibility, prevent the government from using these funds, and let every person know exactly how much money they can count on during their retirement, and regardless of what is going on with the government.
State and Federal Govt: Unemployment Benefits. The payments are too small, and the payment period may be too short for some people – especially for people who worked for many years prior to losing their job. Why not implement this benefit as real insurance? The longer a person is employed, the more payout is given in case of a job loss. If someone wants to purchase more compensation, especially at the start of their working career, this could be done as well.
Local, State, and Federal Govt: Never enough money. It seems every government is always short on funds, especially in poor economy. Why not save money when times are good, and use the surplus during bad times? Oh, that would require the government to exercise fiscal discipline and responsibility – a foreign concept to them. Raising taxes is an easier alternative.
Local Govt: Repaved the library parking lot which was in perfectly good condition while the access road to the local school has been all beat up for years.
Local Govt: Zoning of elementary, middle, and high schools. Parents are unable to chose better schools for their children, and are forced to attend a school in their zone of residence which is often not the best, or even could be further away then a better school in a different zone. Such system allows bad schools to exist. Public schools are paid for by your tax dollars. Public school system is so inefficient that the actual price of education is comparable or costs more than for private schools. Why not privatize public education in many areas, issue to every child a voucher of let's say $10,000 per year, and let the parents decide what school a child will attend? Better schools will get the funds associated with vouchers while poorly performing schools will not. As a result, schools will get an incentive to get better, or their administration and teachers will be replaced.
Federal and State Govt: Why retirement age goes up? If people live longer, wouldn't it make sense to not increase the retirement age so that older people could enjoy their life longer after working hard for so many years? No, the government wants to pay less in social security and other benefits while at the same time collecting more income taxes from older workers.
State and Local Govt: Why fines for traffic and parking violations go to the government? The intent of fines is to punish offenders, and not to generate revenue for the government, right? The collected fines should be distributed as a reward to other drivers who obey traffic and parking rules. Makes sense, right? Wrong! It is an important revenue generator for state and local governments.
State and Local Govt. Doing time instead of fine for traffic and parking violations. Why not offer an offender an alternative to perform a few hours of community service or simply come to a police station and sit there for a few hours as a means of punishment? Because traffic and parking fines is an important revenue generator for state and local governments.
Local Govt: Red light cameras. It has been proven by many studies that red light cameras increase the number of accidents, and not decrease them. Few honest municipalities removed them. However, most of them stay in place, and new red light cameras are being installed every day – all in the name of safety, and with little mentioning what a great source of revenue they are, and how expensive it is to maintain them – all at the taxpayer's expense. Installation of a single red light camera costs approximately $60,000.
Local Govt: No solution for extra parking space. Governments do not offer any solution when there is a shortage of parking space. They simply disallow illegal parking while generating additional revenue from parking tickets. How about allowing drivers to double park for a few minutes while leaving a note with the driver's cellphone number? How about allowing to park at bus stops while leaving enough room between cars so that other people are able to board a bus? How about making a precise schedule of street cleaning in big cities so that drivers can get out of the way for a few minutes, and then park their cars back in the same spot? That's not going to work for the government – too much work to come up with the schedule, and it doesn't bring any additional revenue.
Local Govt: Top paid school superintendents in Nassau County, NY made $350,000 - $550,000 during 2013/2014 school year. There are probably many similar instances in other counties. Can you justify such salaries? Do you have any say regarding what those salaries should be?
Local Govt: No air conditioners in classrooms. School classes often don’t have air conditioners. As a result, children have to suffer from heat during early fall and late spring periods. Purchased in volume, a 12,000 BTU air conditioner could cost no more than $200. For 100 classrooms, that would cost $20,000 – a miniscule amount compared to overall school district budgets of tens of millions of dollars, and compared to the salaries of superintendents of the same districts.
State and Local Govt: Enforcement of speed limits - all in the name of safety, right? Radars and lasers (expensive military technology) are used to enforce arbitrary set fixed speed limits. However, absolutely nothing is being done to use any kind of technology to adjust those speed limits according to traffic flow, weather conditions, time of day, etc. Can you guess why? The latter does not bring any revenue while the former does.
Local Govt: Parking tickets. Municipalities are unable to create extra parking space. However, they will spend your tax dollars to hire more traffic officers, pay their salaries and benefits while diligently writing parking tickets and effectively collecting yet another tax from the same people. At the same time, government vehicles are being illegally parked everywhere and are not getting any tickets. Ticket courts are a joke – they pay salaries and provide benefits out of your taxes to the so called judges who most of the time just shove it in your face and find you guilty of parking illegally. Do you feel the entire system is setup unfairly, and there is nothing you can do?
Local, State, and Federal Govt: Dishonesty, corruption, and crime. You've heard about quite a few scandals involving politicians. Do you think that is it, or what became public is only the tip of the iceberg?
Local, State, and Federal Govt: Nearsightedness of politicians. Every politician is elected for a term. Coupled with little real control from the people, a politician inevitably pursues short term goals. As a result, the government's behavior is zigzagging instead of being consistent through the years.
Local, State, and Federal Govt: Ignorance. When a politician is confronted to explain his action or what he said, oftentimes such politician chooses to simply ignore the requests. There is little people can do about it.
Local, State, and Federal Govt: Big brother. Government law enforcement often sets up roadblocks to check that your vehicle's paperwork is in order. Violators or those who don't comply will be fined, their cars can be impounded, and some may even be taken to jail. Are you able to verify anything the government is doing wrong and punish a government official in the same way? I didn't think so.
State and Federal Govt: Consumer protection. Batteries – heavy duty, super heavy duty, copper top, etc. So much confusion to an average consumer. Rechargeable batteries clearly indicate their capacities – for example 2000 mAh. Why not regular batteries? The more the capacity, the better the battery. It's that simple. A requirement for all batteries to clearly show their capacity would make perfect sense.
State and Federal Govt: Salaries and benefits of politicians. Do you know what they are? Do they make sense to you? Do you have any say as to what they should be? Does the government set their own salaries and benefits? You bet.
Local Govt: Prolonged road repairs. Some construction and road repair projects go on for many months and even years, reducing the number of available lanes, and slowing down traffic every day. There seems to be just a handful of workers at those sites. One can't help but wonder who in their right mind did the planning and why?
Can you offer your own examples of government actions which make no sense to you? Are you getting the feeling that there has to be evil conspiracy involved in all of this?