I give everyone I date the benefit of the doubt. My downfall I guess, I need to learn to be an #######. After all, they get the good women lol. I mean seriously, don't ya always hear that? A woman you're interested in or more often friends with who is a great woman, her guy treats her like SHIZZ
RK, once you tell her the engagement is off you must tell her to move out for the better. She may likely cry and try to manipulate you into changing your mind by making you feel guilty, but if you've made up your mind that this girl is not the ONE, and I think you have, be strong and follow through. It's better for you and in the long run for her as well.
Regarding the nice guy thing, I firmly believe there is something to that. I've known quite a few attractive quality girls who have married guys who were very nice, but too damn nice and by that I mean a mousey kind of nice. And eventually they were wanting for something more out of their husband.
IMO and from my experience, most girls want a guy who is not going to take any crap when called for, has strong opinions and can logically make their argument. Not an A-hole who breaks the law, just someone who takes charge in a situation.
It looks like this girl is running all over you and she knows it and to the point where she probably lost respect for you because you said, "Okay, go ahead, I'll sit here at home w/ my crank in my hand."
The more I review your situation you really need to break things off right quick. Like a band-aid.. a quick sharp break.
<!--EDIT|Over_Easy
Reason for Edit: None given...|1153933345 -->