Jay, this may be a little unfair of me to post this, seeing as how I'm probably the only person on this board that knows you personally, and has met the fiancee. So, if it's a problem with you, let me know and I'll remove my post.
That being said, let me say this first: Jay, you're one of my best friends I have. So I may be a little biased in my opinion of this relationship, but I'll try and stay as neutral as possible, and if I say something that may upset you, I apologize in advance.
I've never really had a good impression of Jules through talking with you about her and reading her myspace items. Seems to me that she may be 27, going on 20/21. Life to her is still about drinking, bar hopping and gambling. I don't think she's ready to move on and be committed to a serious relationship, something more than exclusively dating someone. But that's just my first impression, and it hasn't changed much with the few times I've met her in person.
You on the other hand, can go balls into something with fully seeing the big picture sometimes. Nothing wrong with that, some call that blind dedication and the willingness to make it work no matter the circumstances. Unfortunately, the circumstances here are much bigger, and some due discretion and patience may have been beneficial in this instance.
Jay, no matter what, our family loves you. You're like a brother to me, and my son looks up to as a role model (though he doesn't know any better.
) We hate to see you hurt, we want to see you in a healthy relationship and happy. If there's anything we could do we would, and you know that. But the one thing that really worries us about Jules is her unwillingness to even recognize
your friends. Do you realize how many times we invited both of you guys out to something, and she has ditched out? It's almost like she's not even making an attempt to get to know us. And that worries us because you told us that one of the important factors for any girlfriend of yours is that she has to get along with us and enjoy hanging out with us, especially since we do so many things together all year long. I don't know if she fits that category, or even wants to for that matter.
I don't know bro, she worries me. To me, it seems I've heard about more problems with you guys then good times. To me that feels like a bad sign.
If you want a solid marriage, you have to have a rock solid foundation, something extremely stable. That way a few fights won't crumble the whole relationship. It seems you guys have built a foundation more on sand. It may work right now, but it seems there's already some settling and cracking occuring. And it could only get worse unless you really do something about it.
I can't tell you to cut, bake and run. That's not fair of me to say that since you're such a good friend. I will say that I want to see you happy, and you DESERVE to be happy. You do what you think will make you happy in the long run. But I will tell you my opinion, I have a bad vibe of her.If you guys get married, I could see the marriage being similar to how someone elses we know. Just two people living together, but no real relationship.
On top of all that, I think Jules may have a gambling problem. If she doesn't get that worked out now, then you guys really shouldn't get married or she'll drag you down with her addiction.