Afghanistan....

Even from my safe location here in the U.S. behind my keyboard, I am sure that trying to fight any war anywhere in the Middle East has got to be pretty futile, given the language and cultural barriers, and having an enemy that looks just like your allie.
Being the boots on the ground, intel, front lines, I obviously cannot imagine, other than you must just have to focus on the individual mission at hand, and getting your team back safely, nothing else.
Because I think if you focused on the big picture, it would be pretty overwhelming and discouraging.
Taliban fighters would often blend into normal everyday civilian activities and even engage in simple conversation with our interpreters like every other farmer or person...

As soon as we would move on, they would often attempt to ambush us or conduct surveillance. What they didn't realize we would have layback patrols set up covertly to oversee the area with the assistance of drone and satellites...they would catch them ghosting us.

Even with all the tech we had at our availability, the Taliban fighters were still able to elude many conventional forces and set up IED ambush sites...very effectively I might add.

You are correct, we had no time to consider politics or other rhetoric, we were very aware of the big picture and how our activities fit into that but we had very concise and focused missions to conduct.
 
I'm uninformed...ok.
Yep, Trump would've done it the same way uncle Joe did...lmao.
Trump isn't on board with selling us to China...or their Afghan allies.
I'm not a democrat or a liberal either...thank GOD!
You do acknowledge Trump left the Afghans out of the process and negotiated the surrender with the Taliban right? Even invited them to Camp David, elevating terrorists to the level of the greatest statesman of our time. Or are you a member of the antifact crew?
 
You do acknowledge Trump left the Afghans out of the process and negotiated the surrender with the Taliban right? Even invited them to Camp David, elevating terrorists to the level of the greatest statesman of our time. Or are you a member of the antifact crew?
I believe the intentions of the deal was good, there was also a stern warning about what would happen should the Taliban misbehave.

More about that in the linky below:

 
I've just read where the US won't extend the deadline to get out of Afghanistan...they are between a rock and a hard place....they either comply or be prepared to fight the Taliban...again....and start the whole process over from the beginning...
If american people are still trapped it's not a rock or a hard place you fight for your country men end of story.... biden f'd up the withdrawal he damn well better have the balls to stand up and make sure not a single innocent american or nato civilian gets behead by those barbarians.... I can guarantee every military person would have no problems saving their own.
 
If american people are still trapped it's not a rock or a hard place you fight for your country men end of story.... biden f'd up the withdrawal he damn well better have the balls to stand up and make sure not a single innocent american or nato civilian gets behead by those barbarians.... I can guarantee every military person would have no problems saving their own.
It's very obvious you have read nothing I have written in any posts on this subject.
 
You do acknowledge Trump left the Afghans out of the process and negotiated the surrender with the Taliban right? Even invited them to Camp David, elevating terrorists to the level of the greatest statesman of our time. Or are you a member of the antifact crew?
I'm not antifact.
I said Trump would have handled it differently, he did, and he was.
I'm sure Trump would've just woke up and said, "ok, today's the day, everybody out, and uh oh, we need to ask permission to go back and get U.S. citizens...
Whatever.
We don't agree, and after your little "cave" comment the other day, I could really give a F about your opinion.
No, it's not thin skin, it's just not taking bs from disrespectful people anymore.
I can post my opinion, you can post yours, we can participate in the same threads...we just don't need to speak directly.
 
I'm not antifact.
I said Trump would have handled it differently, he did, and he was.
I'm sure Trump would've just woke up and said, "ok, today's the day, everybody out, and uh oh, we need to ask permission to go back and get U.S. citizens...
Whatever.
We don't agree, and after your little "cave" comment the other day, I could really give a F about your opinion.
No, it's not thin skin, it's just not taking bs from disrespectful people anymore.
I can post my opinion, you can post yours, we can participate in the same threads...we just don't need to speak directly.
Wow, does that mean you gave a F before I posted that? Lol. OK, I like that - no direct communication. See there we ended in agreement! Wheelie on buddy!
 
The Taliban have released a propaganda video in which its fighters appear to be dressed in stolen US military uniforms and carrying US-made assault rifles.

The video, with a musical soundtrack, was aired on propaganda channels affiliated with the insurgent group. It said the group had deployed an elite unit called "Badri 313" to guard locations in Kabul.


The uniforms and weapons brandished by the men appear to be taken from stockpiles that US special forces had provided to the Afghan army.

The insurgents can be seen wielding M4 and M-16 assault rifles, wearing bulletproof vests and helmets with night vision goggles, The Sun reported.

 
I believe the intentions of the deal was good, there was also a stern warning about what would happen should the Taliban misbehave.

More about that in the linky below:

Well, we are looking at Trump's efforts through a different filter but I will say that getting out of Afghanistan was a necessary evil and it would have taken at least the first Biden administration to do it if Trump had not signed the treaty.
 
So does that mean you knew the Afghan forces were simply pawns of NATO and the US when you served there and that they would defect, desert and hand over to the Taliban the moment you looked the other way?
The guys I talked to about this all said the same thing: We keep asking what side these guys are on but they don't think like that. They are on whichever side benefits them on a particular day. They never latched onto the concept of a country or allegiance. That is the fundamental problem with trying to make Afghanistan a country or using afghanis to do it. They just don't think "country".
 
So does that mean you knew the Afghan forces were simply pawns of NATO and the US when you served there and that they would defect, desert and hand over to the Taliban the moment you looked the other way?
Nobody could know this, I trained special forces, they were at least dedicated and motivated..

As for the conventional forces, I had some faith in them but not a whole lot....did I or anyone I know think they would run away and desert in the face of the Taliban...no we didn't and couldn't....
 
The Taliban have released a propaganda video in which its fighters appear to be dressed in stolen US military uniforms and carrying US-made assault rifles.

The video, with a musical soundtrack, was aired on propaganda channels affiliated with the insurgent group. It said the group had deployed an elite unit called "Badri 313" to guard locations in Kabul.


The uniforms and weapons brandished by the men appear to be taken from stockpiles that US special forces had provided to the Afghan army.

The insurgents can be seen wielding M4 and M-16 assault rifles, wearing bulletproof vests and helmets with night vision goggles, The Sun reported.

All during the conflict the Taliban embedded their soldiers into the ANA and these soldiers killed from within...not a new tactic...it got so bad, there were sentries posted behind the training cadre just in case.
 
Some of the headlines coming out of the news are just (to quote Tristan) "dumb." I saw one this morning that read " Impossible to ensure safety of Afghans once Canada, US leave Kabul: experts" I sure don't know what "expert" quoted this but they are pretty thick to think anything else...

....and there are many "dumb" headlines like that....

There is absolutely no way the coalition can airlift that many people out in this short time frame...I imagine half of the people of Afghanistan want to leave....doing this is like trying to airlift everyone out of Chicago in 2 weeks while under threat of attack.

The deadline is looming and unless the US and others want to go back in to fight another 20 yrs, they need to get their rear ends out of there...the Taliban just don't care that there are people still in Afghanistan who want to leave...if we don't get out when they say, I can see commercial airliners being blown up on the tarmac and many coalition soldiers lives' in peril...
 
Back
Top