Just when I thought this administration couldn't get any more boneheaded
'Tis a lot of political angst that amounts to diddly.
The Red Team is just making hay while the sun shines. The pipeline will happen. Everyone knows it.... Prez knows it will happen... TransCanada knows that it will happen.... even that very NBC article you linked to knows it:
And the State Department said the decision was made "without prejudice," meaning TransCanada can submit a new application once a route through environmentally sensitive areas of Nebraska is established.
Russ Girling, TransCanada's president and chief executive officer, said the company plans to do exactly that. If approved, the pipeline could begin operation as soon as 2014, Girling said.
While I am far from a tree-hugger, there are good reasons to hold off pipeline construction in its current form, and force the TransCanada executives to re-think their intended pipeline route. This XL Pipeline project will still happen... and all them "jobs" will happen, etc, etc; this is just a chance for the Repubs to howl/stir up the masses until the permit is granted.
A huge problem is that the current proposed XL pipeline route would cross the Sandhills region, which is over the top of the aquifer. The area is the major regeneration source for the underground watersource. The current Keystone line runs through the eastern part of Nebraska - not through the Sandhills, which is a fairly fragile ecosystem and one of the largest wetland ecosystems in the Western Hemisphere.
A LOT of Nebraskans - many who are hard-core conservative Republicans - get their drinking water from this aquifer.
Believe me, those republican Nebraskans are
ecstatic that Obama nixed the permit until the route gets changed!
So... all these TransCanada executives have to do to re-route the proposed XL line to keep it north of the Aquifier, and then link up this new pipeline segment with the existing Keystone line in the southeastern corner of South Dakota. Then the pipeline permit can be granted. Prez knows this. TransCanada knows this. The pipeline will happen after the Nebraska segment of route is moved north.
The proposed XL pipeline through south Oklahoma/eastern Texas isn't under any scrutiny by the granola-crappers; they must consider this region already too ate-up with Environmental Badness to bother with.
The drinking water-providing Aquifer is, of course, another matter.
In the interim, Prez gets political points (in an election year) with his large constituent of tree-hugging granola-crappers, and the Repubs get to hammer the Dems as job-cutting, anti-energy demons of 'Merica. Win-win for both! And in the end, pipeline still gets built, we still get the jobs, and the oil.